Safety & Security of the SIS
Why insurer-backed SIS payments are dependable — ratings, reserves, guaranty associations, and reinsurance.
An SIS is built to be safe in layers. First, the buyer is out of the picture — an assignment company owes the payments, removing buyer-default risk. Second, those payments are funded by a top-rated life insurer holding mandated reserves and capital. Third, if an insurer ever failed, state guaranty associations provide a backstop. Fourth, insurers spread risk through reinsurance.
The protection layers
- Buyer-credit isolation. The assignment company assumes and funds the obligation immediately; the seller no longer depends on the buyer's solvency.
- Highly rated insurers. Funding carriers are AAA/AA-class (e.g. MetLife / Metropolitan Tower Life, A+ Superior by AM Best).
- Mandated reserves & RBC. Leading carriers run RBC ratios around 400–600%.
- Guaranty-association backstop if an insurer becomes insolvent.
- Reinsurance spreading large or concentrated risks across multiple balance sheets.
Guaranty associations / NOLHGA
Every state operates a life and health insurance guaranty association, coordinated by NOLHGA. The typical coverage for structured-settlement annuity benefits is $250,000 per payee per insurer — raised from $100,000 in 2009 (New York provides $500,000). The system has an annual assessment capacity on the order of $10 billion.
Guaranty-association coverage is a backstop, not a substitute for carrier strength: the $250,000 per-payee limit is far below the value of most SIS arrangements. Sellers with large structured balances ($5–10M over 20 years) may split the obligation across two or more carriers to reduce concentration risk.
Coverage limits and association contact information vary by state. See the 50-State Guaranty Association Reference for a searchable schedule of annuity present-value caps, death-benefit and cash-value limits, aggregate caps, and the contact details for each state's life & health guaranty association.
Credit ratings & the Executive Life lesson
Rating agencies — AM Best (A++/A+ at the top), S&P, Moody's, Fitch — assess each insurer's claims-paying ability. History supplies a cautionary tale: Executive Life (ELIC) and its New York affiliate ELNY — both carrying high A+ ratings — failed in 1991 after over-concentrating in junk bonds; ELNY's wind-down revealed a shortfall of roughly $900 million by 2012. The lesson is not that structured annuities are unsafe — most payees were substantially protected — but that asset quality and diversification behind the rating matter.
Historical safety record
Carriers backing structured settlements and installment sales hold well over $100 billion in reserves, and the record of paying these obligations reliably over decades is the practical foundation of the SIS's safety claim. Even in historical insolvencies, guaranty associations have paid a high share of annuity claims — on the order of 94.7 cents on the dollar in aggregate historically.
↑ Back to top